Chama vs SACCO vs VSLA vs Stokvel vs Sou-Sou: What Is the Difference?

Chama vs SACCO vs VSLA vs stokvel vs sou-sou explained: how each works, who it suits, and how rotating (ROSCA) and accumulating (ASCA) groups differ.

By The AvenaHold Team
 ·  3 min read

Groups that save and lend together exist in most countries, under many names: chama, VSLA, SACCO, stokvel, sou-sou, susu, tanda, chit fund and others. They differ in how money moves, how formal they are and where they are common.

This guide explains the difference between a chama, a SACCO, a VSLA, a stokvel and a sou-sou.

ROSCA vs ASCA: rotating and accumulating savings groups

Underneath all the names there are two basic designs.

Rotating groups (ROSCAs). Everyone contributes the same amount each period, and one member receives the whole pot each time, in turn. After a full round, everyone has paid in and received once. Sou-sous, susus and many “merry-go-round” groups work like this.

Accumulating groups (ASCAs). Members save into a shared pool over a cycle. The pool lends to members for interest, and at the end the savings and profit are shared out. Most chamas and VSLAs work like this.

Some groups mix the two.

Quick comparison

NameWhere it is commonUsually works asFormality
ChamaKenya, East AfricaAccumulating, sometimes rotatingInformal, some register
VSLA (village savings and loan association)Across Africa and Asia, often promoted by NGOsAccumulating, with loans and a share-outInformal, with a set method
SACCO (savings and credit cooperative)East and Southern Africa and elsewhereMember-owned financial cooperativeFormal, registered, usually supervised
StokvelSouth AfricaRotating or accumulating, savings or burialInformal, some register
Sou-sou, susu, esusu, ajoWest Africa, the Caribbean, and diaspora communitiesUsually rotatingInformal
Tanda, cundinaLatin America and diasporaRotatingInformal
Chit fundIndiaRotating with a bidding systemRegulated
Table bankingKenya and East AfricaAccumulating, members lend at meetingsInformal

Chama

A chama is a group of people who pool money for a shared goal: savings, loans or investment. It may rotate payouts, or it may accumulate and lend.

VSLA

A VSLA follows a clear method. Members buy shares, the group lends from the pool, and at the end of a cycle, usually a year, the savings and the profit are shared out. The “cycle” is the defining feature. Many VSLAs are introduced by NGOs, though plenty are started by members themselves.

SACCO

A SACCO is a cooperative owned by its members. It can offer savings accounts, loans and other services. Because it handles larger sums and serves more people, it’s usually more formal than a savings group, with registration and oversight. How that works differs from country to country, so check what applies where you live.

Stokvel

A stokvel is the South African version: a group that saves or pools money regularly, sometimes for one purpose such as groceries, a burial fund or investments.

Sou-sou, susu, esusu and ajo

These are different names for a rotating group in West Africa, the Caribbean and their diaspora communities. Each member contributes, and each member takes a turn collecting the pot.

Which is right for you: chama, VSLA, SACCO or stokvel?

  • You want a lump sum on a schedule, with no lending: a rotating group.
  • You want to save across a year and borrow from the pool: an accumulating group such as a chama or VSLA.
  • You want something bigger and more formal: a SACCO.

Whatever you choose, the foundations are the same: written rules, clear records, and more than one person confirming payments. Start with how to run a savings group, and when you’re ready, see how the year ends in how a share-out works.

See also: how to start a chama or VSLA and a family savings group across countries.

Good to know

Is a chama the same as a VSLA?
They are similar. Both are member-run groups that save regularly and lend to members. The names are used in different places and by different organisations.
What is the difference between a SACCO and a savings group?
A SACCO is a more formal financial cooperative, usually registered and supervised, while a savings group is typically a small, informal, member-run circle.
What is a sou-sou?
A sou-sou, also called susu, esusu or ajo in different places, is usually a rotating group where each member receives the whole pot in turn.