Lenders quote interest in different ways. A flat rate, a reducing-balance rate, an APR and an effective rate can all describe the same loan with different numbers. Comparing a 3% monthly flat rate with a 36% annual rate, for instance, can lead to the wrong conclusion. This article explains each term and shows how to compare loans on the same basis.
The terms
- Flat rate. Interest is calculated on the original loan for the whole term.
- Reducing-balance rate. Interest is calculated on the amount still owed each period.
- Nominal rate. The stated rate before taking compounding into account, for example 3% a month, or 36% a year if you multiply by 12.
- APR (annual percentage rate). A yearly rate intended to include the interest and mandatory fees, to allow comparison. How it is calculated differs between countries, so check the local definition.
- Effective annual rate (EAR). The true yearly rate after compounding: EAR = (1 + monthly rate) ^ 12 - 1.
What is the difference between APR and flat rate?
A flat rate charges interest on the original loan amount for the whole term, even though you repay the loan gradually. APR is a yearly rate meant to show the full cost of borrowing, including mandatory fees. A loan quoted at a flat rate has a higher APR than the flat rate suggests, because the balance you owe falls each month while the interest charge does not. For a short answer on which to compare, see APR vs interest rate.
How to convert a flat rate to APR
- Work out the monthly instalment: (loan + loan x flat rate x months) / months.
- Find the monthly rate that makes those instalments equal the cash you received.
- Multiply that monthly rate by 12 to get the APR.
A spreadsheet does step 2 with RATE. For example, a 1,000,000 loan at 3% flat per month over 6 months gives an APR of about 59%. The full worked example, with fees, is in how to calculate the APR of a flat-rate loan.
How can APR be lower than the interest rate?
Usually APR is equal to or higher than the interest rate, because it adds fees. It can be lower in two cases:
- The “interest rate” is an effective annual rate and the APR is nominal. A loan charging 3% a month compounded has a nominal APR of 36% and an effective annual rate of about 42.6%. If the 42.6% is called the interest rate, the 36% APR is lower.
- The product includes credits that offset costs, such as cashback or a lender credit counted in the APR calculation. Rules differ by country, so check how the lender defines it.
APR vs EAR: what is the difference?
APR (in its common nominal form) multiplies the periodic rate by the number of periods in a year and ignores compounding. EAR, the effective annual rate, includes compounding: EAR = (1 + monthly rate) ^ 12 - 1. For a 3% monthly rate, APR is 36% and EAR is about 42.6%. The more often interest compounds, the bigger the gap. Compare loans using the same measure on both.
Example 1: a flat monthly rate
A loan of 1,000,000 for 6 months at 3% per month flat.
- Total interest = 1,000,000 x 0.03 x 6 = 180,000
- Instalment = 1,180,000 / 6 = 196,667
To find the true cost, ask: what monthly reducing-balance rate gives an instalment of 196,667 over 6 months on a 1,000,000 loan? The answer is about 4.94% per month.
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Quoted flat rate | 3% per month |
| Equivalent reducing-balance rate | about 4.94% per month |
| Simple annual (4.94% x 12) | about 59% |
| Effective annual rate | about 78% |
So “3% flat per month” costs about as much as 59% a year on a reducing balance, and about 78% a year once compounding is counted. See flat vs reducing-balance interest.
Example 2: a flat annual rate
A loan of 1,000,000 for one year at 12% flat per year, repaid in 12 monthly instalments.
- Total interest = 1,000,000 x 0.12 = 120,000
- Instalment = 1,120,000 / 12 = 93,333
The true reducing-balance rate is about 1.79% per month, which is about 21.5% a year (simple) and about 23.7% effective. A “12%” loan costs roughly twice that, because you repay the balance every month and still pay interest on the full amount.
Example 3: converting a monthly rate
A reducing-balance loan at 3% per month:
- Nominal annual: 3% x 12 = 36%
- Effective annual: 1.03 ^ 12 - 1 = about 42.6%
A rate quoted per month looks small. Always convert it to a yearly figure for comparison.
How to compare loans
- Find the total you will repay. Total repayment is the clearest number to compare.
- Compare on the same basis. Convert every quote to an annual reducing-balance rate or APR. Where possible, ask the lender for the APR.
- Include all fees. Arrangement fees, insurance, processing fees and penalty charges raise the real cost.
- Compare the term. A longer term lowers the instalment but increases total interest.
- Check how interest is calculated on late payments.
A quick check is to divide total interest by loan and by years. If a flat quote gives total interest of 12% of the loan for one year with monthly repayments, the true yearly rate is nearly double.
A shortcut for flat rates
For a loan repaid in equal monthly instalments, the true annual rate is roughly twice the flat annual rate when the loan is repaid steadily over the term. The exact figure needs a calculation, as in the examples. Use a spreadsheet function such as RATE, or the formula in savings group loan calculator explained.
Which is “better” for a borrower?
A lower effective rate and a lower total repayment are better for a borrower. The quoted rate alone does not tell you. Ask for the instalment, the total repayment and the number of instalments, then compare. If you already have debts, see how to get out of debt.
This is general information, not financial advice. Legal definitions of APR vary by country.