Flat vs Reducing-Balance Interest on Group Loans, Explained

Flat rate vs reducing balance interest on chama, VSLA and SACCO loans: the formula and a worked example showing why 3% flat costs far more than 3% reducing.

By The AvenaHold Team
 ·  4 min read

Savings groups, chamas, VSLAs and SACCOs often quote a loan interest rate such as 3% a month without saying how it is calculated. Two groups can quote the same rate and charge borrowers very different amounts, because the calculation method differs. This article explains the two common methods, flat rate and reducing balance, with a worked example.

How to calculate interest on a group loan: an example

Suppose a member borrows 1,000,000 (in any currency) from the group. The loan is repaid over 6 months and the group charges 3% per month.

Method 1: flat rate

The group works out the interest once, on the full amount, and spreads it across the months.

  • Interest: 1,000,000 x 3% x 6 = 180,000
  • Total the borrower repays: 1,180,000
  • Monthly instalment: 196,667

The flat method is simple to explain and easy to calculate by hand, which is why many groups use it.

Method 2: reducing balance

Here interest is charged only on the amount still owed. Every instalment pays some interest and some of the loan itself, so the balance shrinks, and so does the interest.

MonthInterestPrincipal repaidInstalmentBalance left
130,000154,598184,598845,402
225,362159,235184,598686,167
320,585164,012184,598522,155
415,665168,933184,598353,222
510,597174,001184,598179,221
65,377179,221184,5980
  • Total interest: about 107,585
  • Total the borrower repays: about 1,107,585
  • Monthly instalment: about 184,598

Flat rate vs reducing balance: what the difference means

FlatReducing balance
Total interest180,000about 107,585
Monthly instalment196,667about 184,598
Borrower paysabout 72,415 less

In month five, under the flat method, the borrower has repaid more than 80% of the loan but is still charged interest as if the full 1,000,000 were owed. Measured against the balance actually outstanding each month, a flat 3% per month is equivalent to about 4.9% per month on a reducing balance.

The reducing-balance loan formula

The monthly instalment on a reducing-balance loan is:

instalment = loan x r / (1 - (1 + r) ^ -n)

where r is the monthly interest rate as a decimal (3% is 0.03) and n is the number of months. In our example, 1,000,000 x 0.03 / (1 - 1.03 ^ -6) comes to about 184,598. The flat-rate instalment is simply (loan + loan x r x n) / n.

A third method some groups use

Many groups skip the table altogether. Each month, the borrower pays interest on the principal still outstanding, and repays the principal in whatever amounts they can manage. This is reducing-balance interest in practice, and it’s very flexible. The price of that flexibility is careful record keeping: someone has to track every repayment and the date it was made.

Which loan interest method should a chama or VSLA use?

Either method is acceptable if the group chooses it deliberately and records it.

  • If simplicity matters most, flat is easy to work out by hand. If you choose it, tell every borrower in plain words the total they’ll repay, not just the rate.
  • If fairness to the borrower matters most, reducing balance is usually seen as the fairer method, because it charges only for money still in use.
  • Whatever you pick, write it in your rules, and show the borrower the repayment total before they commit.

Checklist before a loan is approved

  • The borrower knows the total they’ll repay, in currency units.
  • The interest method is written in the group’s rules.
  • The monthly instalment and every due date are recorded.
  • Late payments are handled by the written rule, not by feelings. See what to do when a member cannot repay.

The method also affects every member at share-out: the interest borrowers pay is what builds the profit pool that everyone shares at the end of the cycle. See how a share-out works, and if you’re setting up a group, start with how to run a savings group.

To express either method as a yearly rate, see APR vs flat rate vs effective interest rate and how to calculate the APR of a flat-rate loan.

Good to know

What is flat-rate interest?
Flat-rate interest is charged on the original loan amount for the whole term, even though the borrower pays the loan down over time.
What is reducing-balance interest?
Reducing-balance interest is charged only on the amount still owed. As the borrower repays principal, the interest charged each month falls.
Which method should a savings group use?
Either can work, but the group must choose one, write it down and make sure every member understands what it costs. Reducing balance is usually seen as fairer to the borrower; flat is simpler to calculate.