Monthly Contributions vs Shares in a Savings Group: Which Is Better?

Fixed monthly contributions or shares? How each works in a chama or VSLA, a worked share-price example, and how to choose the right model for your group.

By The AvenaHold Team
 ·  3 min read

Savings groups collect money in one of two ways: a fixed monthly contribution, where everyone pays the same, or shares, where each member chooses how many fixed-price units to buy. Both are used by chamas, VSLAs and similar groups. The choice affects how easy the group is to run, how fair it feels to members on different incomes, and how the share-out is calculated.

Fixed monthly contributions

Every member pays the same amount on the same schedule, for example 50 per month.

Advantages

  • Simple to explain and to record.
  • Easy to check: every row in the record should show the same amount.
  • No member has to decide how much to save each month.
  • The share-out is easy to calculate when all members have saved the same amount.

Disadvantages

  • Members on lower incomes may struggle, and members on higher incomes may want to save more.
  • If someone cannot pay in a difficult month, they are in default instead of simply buying fewer shares.

Shares

A share has a fixed price, for example 10. Members buy any number of shares at each meeting, up to a limit set by the group, such as five shares per meeting.

Advantages

  • Members on different incomes can take part on fair terms.
  • Members can save more in good months and less in lean months.
  • Profit is divided by shares, which keeps the arithmetic fair.

Disadvantages

  • A little more record keeping: the number of shares per member each meeting.
  • Members who buy many shares late in the cycle have had less time in the pool unless the group weights shares for timing. See how a share-out works.
  • Without a limit, a few members can dominate the pool.

Worked example: how shares divide the profit

A group sells shares at 10 each. At the end of the cycle:

MemberShares heldSavings
A40400
B25250
C10100
Total75750

The group earned a profit of 90 after expenses. Profit per share = 90 / 75 = 1.20.

MemberSharesProfit sharePayout
A4048448
B2530280
C1012112
Total7590840

The same arithmetic applies to fixed contributions: each member’s share of the profit equals their share of total savings.

Setting a share price and limits

  • Share price. Choose a price that the lowest-income member can afford to buy at least one of. A very high share price recreates the problem of fixed contributions.
  • Maximum shares per meeting. A limit, such as five shares per meeting, stops a few members from holding most of the pool.
  • Minimum. Require at least one share per meeting if you want regular saving.
  • Constant price. Do not change the share price during the cycle. If it changes, the profit calculation becomes difficult to check.

How to choose

If your group…Consider
Has members with similar incomes and wants simplicityFixed contribution
Has members with very different or irregular incomesShares
Is new and has no record keeper with experienceFixed contribution
Wants to lend a lot and let members save moreShares

Whichever you choose, write it in your group rules before the first payment and keep a record of each payment. For a full set of decisions, see how to run a savings group, and for starting small, see how to start a chama with little money.

Good to know

What is a share in a VSLA?
A share is a fixed-price unit of savings. Each member buys as many shares as they choose, up to a limit, and receives a return in proportion to the number of shares they hold at the end of the cycle.
Is a fixed contribution simpler than shares?
Yes. A fixed contribution needs no choices from members and is easy to record. Shares give more flexibility when incomes differ.
Can members change their number of shares during the cycle?
Only if the rules allow it. Many groups let members buy any number of shares each meeting up to a weekly or monthly limit, and do not allow shares to be returned during the cycle.